ORIGINAL: Misanthropy
The info you provide would be from a study.
Yes, here is another:
http://www.nutrition.org/cgi/content/abstract/134/10/2888S "The proposed or advertised ergogenic effect of many supplements is based on a presumptive metabolic pathway and may not necessarily translate to quantifiable changes in a variable as broadly defined as exercise performance. L-arginine is a conditionally essential amino acid that has received considerable attention due to potential effects on growth hormone secretion and nitric oxide production. In some clinical circumstances (e.g., burn injury, sepsis) in which the demand for arginine cannot be fully met by de novo synthesis and normal dietary intake, exogenous arginine has been shown to facilitate the maintenance of lean body mass and functional capacity. "
It can go either way, get 10 people to say this and i can get 10 people to say that. You never know something until you get some experience YOURSELF and make you own opinion and not someone elses "study."
This is why I listen to the people who have laid the foundation to which everything we do as bodybuilders is built.
Anything that you intake has a possiblility to cause some damage. By taking the proper steps necessary to make sure what you supplement is safe. Honestly, i couldnt tell if cellmass worked or not.
Right, but my point isn't neccessairly about damage. I am a college student, so money is tight, and I would hate to see my fellow bodybuilder go out, waste money on a product that 1. has no evidence that the main ingredient provides any ergogenic aid, 2. could be potentially dangerous. But, any supplement can be dangerous if misused, ex. extremely high doses.
Supplementation is a fairly new science and of couse it will take time to be regulated by larger watchdog groups. So leave it up to the consumer to make the choice to do supplementation or not. Just educate yourself from many difference sources before you jump in.
I agree, however the watchdog (or FDA, more like the money hungry carnivore :P) is arriving alot sooner than most think. As far as education, why would you look anywhere else than a revered scientist? And no, supplement companies don't have my trust, unless they can provide a conclusive lab analysis for a product.
I see what you are saying, and I know that most people probably won't listen to me because they are too caught up in the hype, however, again, why wouldn't you listen to people who study the human body for a living? Why be a "guinea pig" for a product when there is NO evidence that suggests the main ingredient helps their cause? That is essentially the choice you're making. So then, I leave it up to you, the consumer to make that decision.
Jason
PS - Sorry as if I came off as a douche bag in that post, that was not my intention, but I am very passionate about science, research, bodybuilding and wellness.