ORIGINAL: brihead301
ORIGINAL: kingkebabs
I don't like the training methods. The majority of people who use HST are beginners who would grow from walking up a flight of stairs, evident by the fact they are following a "one workout suits all" routine, blind to their own individual need. The name of the routine itself is void.
In the case of the original poster, this may be applicable, but overall from the wider perspective it's not better than every other blanket routine out there regardless of how many undertrained people boast of thier outlandish gains.
I agree with you about the "blanket routine" statement. I've actually been trying to work on designing my own hypertrophy routine based on what I've learned in the past year. For example, I respond well to higher reps on squats, but with the occasional low rep days; low rep deads all the time; varying reps for bench press and overhead press; low reps for rowing; pull-ups and chin-ups I do high reps, high reps for lunges; etc...
Do you have any pointers about how to go about making your own routine designed to suit the individual needs?
It's the best way forward.
Everyone can draw conclusions relative to their own body by following these set routines, but the idea is to cherrypick the methods in these routines which are most beneficial, and of course, those that are not.
If you note response from a particular method or change, ask yourself if the same principles / factors can be applied elsewhere. i.e Instead of relishing in the fact that you may have found that higher reps make your chest grow, start thinking about applying this method to another movement / muscle which is not too indifferent in size and function from the chest. i.e Would your shoulders also benefit from the same approach?
Individual need and response is obviously going to vary from each person to the next, so theres no concrete advice I can give with regards to setting up a routine as there are too many factors involved which will determine the structure of the persons training.
These factors might include:
Response, inclusive of growth, strength and overtraining (CNS response).
Imbalance; muscular and or skeletal. The persons posture / spine may be innapropriate if not dangerous to hold a heavy load on the back. Their shoulders may be protracted emphasising this problem and limiting the flexibility required to perform other movements safely and efficiently, though underdeveloped muscle or improper bone growth. The person may have to work for years before they can perform a deadlift safely. Some may never be in a state to deadlift......etc
It really depends upon the individuals need.
It's quite laughable when you you consider how many different possibilities of factors there are, yet so many people follow a set "one size fits all" protocol. Reffering to the initial point of response and overtraining, people have varying lifestyles. Some people might work on a building site lifting loads day in day out, whilst the next person sits at a computer all day. The construction worker may overtrain after only a few weeks training 1-2 times per week, whilst the office worker can thrash out 5 days per week with the same intensity....but with a bent upper back...
Ranting further...
How many blanket routines offer an alternative less / more intensive versions of the program based upon daily, rate of non-training physical activity, sectioning into "inactive" / "moderately active" / "very active"? (which is all it takes for a more effective solution). Answer: none.
As mentioned I consider routines such as HST as nothing more than a starting point, for the reasons mentioned above and more. There shouldn't ever be an excuse for an experienced person to resort to such routines. After the initial growth spurt of "beginners gains" people should switch on and start absoring methods enabling them to peice together the beneficial principles into a whole bigger picture; an effective, individual tailoried routine, (without using the rule as an excuse to slack off).
There's too many people who have years of experience under their belts still running with this type of routine. It's ignorance at it's best and quite typical of us as a race. We question nothing and just roll on with the program eating whatever is held to our face.
I hope I answered your question someone in there.